rrr

Discussions:

Latest comment: 2 months ago by SaibaK in topic Inclusion of acclaim by filmmakers for RRR

Excessive citations

I'll list in this section some of the references that I remove as part of WP:CITEKILL so that they could potentially be used for sourcing other relevant content.

More to come — DaxServer (t · m · c) 09:00, 25 March 2022 (UTC) (Updated: — DaxServer (t · m · c) 11:58, 19 May 2022 (UTC))

    26 July is wrong, announced as 30 July only. I mean who releases their film on a Sunday? -- Ab207 (talk) 09:41, 25 March 2022 (UTC)
      @Ab207 This ref [1] says Anirudh Ravichander was roped in for the song promo. Could it be added in casting or simply at the song promo sentence in design? — DaxServer (t · m · c) 08:44, 27 March 2022 (UTC)
        DaxServer, definitely not in the cast section, its reserved for the actual film. Many playback singers of the film have appeared in the lyrical songs, so Anirudh is not special. I'm neutral on adding in other section. -- Ab207 (talk) 09:57, 27 March 2022 (UTC)
          @Ab207 P.S. "Bheem for Ramaraju" in March 2020 is missing — DaxServer (t · m · c) 17:38, 6 April 2022 (UTC)
  • I'll review the article soon-ish — DaxServer (t · m · c) 14:42, 12 September 2022 (UTC)

Semi-protected edit request on 31 July 2023 (5)

Under Release, Theatrical: 'The High Court quashed the petition in March, observing that film did not tarnish the reputation of two revolutionaries as claimed.'

Please change 'reputation of two revolutionaries' to 'reputation of the two revolutionaries'. Amecabra (talk) 14:38, 31 July 2023 (UTC)

    rrr  Done ULPS (talk) 18:38, 31 July 2023 (UTC)

Page move

Move preformed without explanation or discussion on August 9; RRR (disambiguation) had also been moved on April 2 with no explanation. However, the moove seems to have been justified based on the disproportionate pageviews of this article compared to others on the DAB page.

Pageviews for this article, its former title, RRR (disambiguation), and the next seven most popular articles at that dab page between April 3 and December 3: in decreasing order, Rayman Raving Rabbids, RRR (soundtrack), The three Rs, Red River Rivalry, Regional Ring Road, River Runs Red, and Ridge Racer Revolution. –LaundryPizza03 (d) 08:10, 4 December 2023 (UTC)

Addressing the (mis)uses of history in RRR

The film opens with a disclaimer that the work is entirely fictional; however, since the two leading characters are based on two central Telugu historical figures, there is a certain responsibility owed to depicting them with a degree of historical integrity. In order to address these nuanced issues, I have added a section titled '(Mis)use of History,' which delves into the complexities surrounding historical accuracy and the adequacy of disclaimers. This section aims to foster a discussion on how the film navigates the fine line between fiction and historical representation, inviting contributors to share their insights on the challenges and ethical considerations involved. I encourage fellow editors to review this section and provide feedback to ensure a balanced and informed portrayal of the historical context within the film. OwlzOfMinerva (talk) 03:09, 7 December 2023 (UTC)

    I'd argue that this section entirely violates WP:NOR, as it looks entirely like an original analysis/essay about historical disclaimers. The proper way to include something like this is if it is discussed in reliable sources, where then it'd probably be included in the Reception section as what those original sources thought about the film's usage of history. Plenty of fictional works go wildly off the rails of real history, the place with your own discussion to start this discussion is neither this page nor probably Wiki English. As such, I have reverted this edit. 2607:FEA8:1E1F:EE00:C614:C5A1:E940:5260 (talk) 04:22, 9 December 2023 (UTC)

Inclusion of acclaim by filmmakers for RRR

RRR is a unique Indian movie that has received massive acclaim globally - something that's not shared by any other movie and is inspirational for the entire Indian film ecosystem.

The section below highlights that unique achievement.


Reception of RRR by international Filmmakers

Steven Spielberg praised RRR, saying "I couldn't believe my eyes – it was like eye candy...it was extraordinary to look at and experience." Rajamouli said in response "I can almost get up from the chair and do a dance – it means a lot to me."

James Cameron said that he liked RRR so much that he watched it twice and praised the screenplay, direction and music direction of the movie.

Edgar Wright said that RRR was "an absolute blast" and said it was "The only film I have ever seen where the intermission card itself got a round of applause."

Adam McKay publicly expressed support to RRR for the Oscar awards race.

James Gunn said that about RRR that he "Totally dug it."

Russo Brothers have publicly expressed their appreciation for RRR and its director SS Rajamouli . Joe Russo mentioned “I’ve seen RRR, and it’s amazing." He further mentions "What I think is so amazing about [RRR] is the emotion it evokes, combined with the spectacle."

Scott Derrickson tweeted "To celebrate my birthday last night, my wife, kids and I watched @RRRMovie — what an awesomely outrageous roller coaster of a movie. Loved it"

Joe Dante called RRR a brutal portrait that depicts the horrors of British colonisation and said that "I bet you’ve never seen anything quite like it"

Daniel Kwan lauded the film, saying "While a lot of the blockbusters we're making in the states tend to have self aware, cheeky characters trapped in self-serious filmmaking, RRR was all heart-on-its-sleeve sincerity wrapped up in the most ridiculous over the top execution. So much to love."


This section has been thoroughly cited (as can be seen from the history version of this page from 26-27 Jan 2024) with all the examples, but is continuously being removed by the user below, whom I address below to better understand the contention:

@Falimy: May I ask why are you removing this section? Is there a problem with citation? Is the acclaim by Steven Speilberg or James Cameron not considered noteworthy by you? Is there any other format that you'll prefer? Are there any other issues that you have noticed?

Kindly clearly articulate the reasons here in the Talk page so that we can understand your reason for persistently editing this section out. SaibaK (talk) 01:54, 3 February 2024 (UTC)

Tags:

rrr Excessive citationsrrr Semi-protected edit request on 31 July 2023 (5)rrr Page moverrr Addressing the (mis)uses of history in RRRrrr Inclusion of acclaim by filmmakers for RRRrrr

🔥 Trending searches on Wiki English:

Chester BenningtonCarlo Ancelotti2024 Iranian strikes in IsraelOpinion polling for the next United Kingdom general electionMia KhalifaRichard Gadd2024 ICC Men's T20 World CupJames VI and IList of countries and dependencies by populationAshwatthamaM. Night ShyamalanJason StathamNehal WadheraThe Eras TourMurder trial of O. J. SimpsonJonathan NolanJohnny DeppDouble or Nothing (2024)Christopher NolanList of constituencies of the Lok SabhaList of states and territories of the United StatesColumbia UniversityAmar Singh ChamkilaThailandVictoria BeckhamTesla, Inc.Lucian GraingePremaluRoman GabrielCherJack AntonoffRobert F. KennedyAEW DynastyBrian PeckBernard ArnaultEarthFTW Championship2024 Indian general election in KarnatakaDune (franchise)George W. BushJeffrey DahmerRishi SunakRwandaKyle MacLachlanBangladeshList of Young Sheldon episodesNapoleonRudolf HössEuropeX-Men '97Giancarlo EspositoTelegram (software)Kelly HuHeartbreak High (2022 TV series)April 22EnshittificationA Gentleman in MoscowJustin HartleyCloud seedingGoogle MapsJefferson DavisOrlando BloomJoe O'Connor (snooker player)Murder of Junko FurutaJennifer GarnerMr Bates vs The Post OfficeEl ClásicoWrestleMania XLDune MessiahTaiwanLovely RunnerImmaculate (2024 film)Character class (Dungeons & Dragons)Michael J. FoxTed LassoDan Schneider🡆 More